Files
pipelines/docs/reference-workflow-results.md
T
alan c42a19f7d3 Improve workflow UI, retain stage diffs, and add portable pipeline transfers
Make OpenCode authoring responsive and expand the managed skill references. Add conflict-aware import/export, real-provider reference workflows, and tracked V2 generation for reliable budget accounting.
2026-10-10 20:55:42 +01:00

81 lines
4.3 KiB
Markdown

# Reference validation — October 10, 2026
Execution: existing Docker installation, Linux `aarch64`, OpenCode **v2.0.20**,
model **opencode-go/deepseek-v4.1-flash**. The test binaries were compiled from the
current checkout and run against a separate SQLite database and isolated fixtures.
No definitions were published to the normal server database and no phone alerts
were sent. Notification checks used an isolated local HTTP endpoint.
| Reference workflow | Live result | Duration |
|---|---|---|
| Incident extraction → report | Passed: exact incident evidence/counts, handoff, session readback and local success receipt | 6.63s |
| Edit → independently verify | Passed: exact file bytes, untouched fixtures, harness-run `cmp`, completed read/edit/shell evidence, retained stage diff | 14.60s |
| Missing required input | Passed: deliberate blocked outcome terminates as failed; missing file not invented; read attempt and local failure receipt retained | 4.21s |
| Accounting and one-token budget | Initially failed the acceptance test; passed after the accounting fix below | 2.43s on focused rerun |
## Defect found and fixed
The first accounting run succeeded despite a one-token limit. Its retained V2
session had **no messages and zero usage counters**, even though `/generate`
returned a valid result. Polling that session treated placeholder zeros as known
accounting and did not enforce the intended limit.
Budgeted V2 text calls now use tracked `/prompt` → `/wait` → message readback,
with **all tools denied**. Their messages are retained in the stage audit, usage
is read from the tracked session, and a completed token-budgeted response with
zero reported tokens fails closed. Native V1 handling and unbudgeted text
generation keep their existing paths.
The focused live rerun retained **952 reported tokens and $0.00016440**, failed
with `stage budget exceeded`, and stopped its owned session. This is reported
usage, not an independently reconciled provider bill. A one-token limit can be
overshot by a single in-flight request; this run demonstrates exhaustion handling,
not an exact hard cap or proof of immediate mid-stream cancellation.
The three previously passing workflows were not charged again. Their copied
artifacts were rechecked with current independent assertions; the fixed accounting
artifacts were rechecked separately. There has **not** been a fresh full-suite live
run of all four cases after the fix.
## Evidence and reproduction
Retained container directories for this trial:
- `/data/reference-validation/pipelines-reference-284076920`: first complete run.
- `/data/reference-validation/pipelines-reference-2247403140`: fixed accounting rerun.
Each has isolated SQLite history, pinned definitions, run/session JSON, fixture
files and `report.json`. Host copies are in the session's approved temporary
directory under `reference-first/` and `reference-accounting-fixed/`.
Commands that performed live inference:
```sh
docker exec -e PIPELINES_REFERENCE_LIVE=1 \
-e PIPELINES_REFERENCE_MODEL=opencode-go/deepseek-v4.1-flash \
-e PIPELINES_REFERENCE_DIR=/data/reference-validation \
pipelines-pipelines-1 /data/reference-validation/reference-20261010.test \
-test.run '^TestReferenceWorkflowsLive$' -test.v -test.timeout 15m
docker exec -e PIPELINES_REFERENCE_LIVE=1 \
-e PIPELINES_REFERENCE_MODEL=opencode-go/deepseek-v4.1-flash \
-e PIPELINES_REFERENCE_DIR=/data/reference-validation \
pipelines-pipelines-1 /data/reference-validation/reference-20261010-fixed.test \
-test.run '^TestReferenceWorkflowsLive/accounting-and-budget$' -test.v -test.timeout 5m
```
`TestReferenceArtifactsReview` rechecks copied run JSON/fixtures without inference;
`PIPELINES_REFERENCE_REVIEW_DIR` selects the copy and `-run` selects its cases.
See [reference workflows](reference-workflows.md) for a fresh run and its opt-in,
cost, retention and safety boundaries.
## Remaining unverified
- Other models/providers and native V1 schema/tool compatibility.
- Real ntfy authentication/storage and actual phone reception.
- Actual provider outages, timeouts, long-stream interruption and retry behavior.
- General workflow correctness beyond these bounded fixtures.
The fix is in the source/test binaries, **not deployed to the installed Docker
server**. Rebuild the installation when ready to use it for ordinary runs.