# Assistant bubble before response tokens ## Behavior - Send inserts the optimistic user turn and starts a display-only assistant response shell immediately, before draft persistence or the server reply. - The normal assistant bubble contains three animated dots while no answer body exists, including reasoning-only and tool-only responses. Tool/reasoning chips stay below the bubble. First answer content replaces the dots. - No fabricated assistant message enters stored history or the transcript cache. Rejection, a terminal step, or reconnect clears local waiting state. A queued follow-up does not add a second response shell. Pending operator decisions suppress the generating indicator. - Animation rebuilds only the dots, not the transcript. Reduced-motion users receive a static ellipsis; accessibility announces “Assistant is responding”. ## Verification - Full `flutter test`: **1,900 passed**. Ten targeted new tests also passed on the final checkout; `flutter analyze` is clean. - Tests cover immediate appearance despite a blocked draft write, acceptance and user echoes, reasoning/tools before text, animation changes, first text, rejection, queued prompts, terminal steps, and reduced motion. - Isolated release web build: `build/chat-response-pending-web`. Real Material and Cupertino browser probes sent only fixture prompts and checked the pre-frame bubble, changing dot pixels, tool-only state, and text replacement. Inspected captures: `build/chat-response-pending-{material,cupertino}/`. - No pre-change screenshot was captured. The source diff shows the prior missing assistant row before frames and the omission of the bubble for tool-only rows. ## Pixel 9 Pro XL - Exercised the actual thread on `47241FDAS00DLK` using the isolated native entry `tool/chat_response_pending_fixture.dart`, which has no server connection and an in-memory draft store. No test prompts were sent to real operator chats. - Native captures verify the bubble before any response frame, above a tool-only footer, and then replaced by answer text. A four-second recording sampled the dots' exact semantics bounds: **19 sampled frames, 19 distinct pixel hashes**. Evidence: `build/chat-response-pending-pixel9/`. - Restored the normal app release **0.1.29882493** after the fixture test with `adb install -r`; normal Pipelines UI and installed version verified. App data and sign-in preserved. Original display/density/power/timeout settings verified restored; device capture files removed; all recorders completed. - Normal APK: `build/chat-response-pending-apk/pipelines.apk`. No website or public update-feed publication, shared-service restart, or Fold use.