From b82e89f66fedb94afe338acb4dfbb8f16d088486 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Alan Silva Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2026 19:55:24 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Record final deck geometry performance comparison and raster limits --- app/notes/mobile-quick-switch-profile.md | 45 +++++++++++++++++++++++- 1 file changed, 44 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/app/notes/mobile-quick-switch-profile.md b/app/notes/mobile-quick-switch-profile.md index 8674a280..92e2d28c 100644 --- a/app/notes/mobile-quick-switch-profile.md +++ b/app/notes/mobile-quick-switch-profile.md @@ -29,7 +29,7 @@ helper now uses the mathematically equivalent affine transform for these cards, while actual Flip/Rolodex rotations keep perspective. Regression verifies the same projected points instead of requiring an unnecessary perspective matrix. -## Quiet before/after confirmation +## Intermediate geometry comparison (superseded by final comparison below) Two repetitions × six warmed touch switches per build, same fixture and 850 ms cadence. Root paused other builds/tests/captures for this comparison. Before is @@ -69,3 +69,46 @@ Tests cover no repeated child-constraint layout as painted height changes, fixed occupied chrome during a fade, actual resting peek height, retained chat drafts for every style and equivalent affine projection. Integration browser review remains with the parent task. + + +## Final release geometry comparison + +Repeated the quiet pair after the final deck polish: the incoming card is already +full-height behind the outgoing opaque front, avoiding a blank gap at the top. +Both builds use exactly that same geometry and opaque surface fill (3daf9ce0). +Only the fixed viewport/chrome layout and affine flat-depth optimization differ. +Two repetitions × six warmed switches each, same rich fixture and 850 ms cadence; +root paused other builds/tests/captures. These final results supersede the earlier +geometry's apparent 25% rAF-tail improvement. + +| Metric | Cost fixes disabled | Cost fixes enabled | +| --- | ---: | ---: | +| Flutter build p50 | 9.0 ms | 1.6 ms | +| Flutter build p95 | 39.7 ms | 20.6 ms | +| Flutter build sum | 895.4 ms | 502.8 ms | +| Total frame p50 | 45.7 ms | 39.5 ms | +| Total frame p95 | 79.2 ms | 78.8 ms | +| Raster p95 | 58.4 ms | 71.0 ms | +| Browser rAF interval p95 | 66.7 ms | 66.7 ms | +| Long tasks (>50 ms) | 36 | 23 | +| Flutter frames recorded | 86 | 96 | + +The layout fix reduces typical build work by about 82%, and typical total frame +cost by about 14%. **Raster tail worsens, rAF p95 does not improve, and total-frame +p95 is essentially unchanged.** Fixed full-size content behind a changing paint +clip still has renderer/filter cost; this patch does not solve that cost or +prove smooth native-device FPS. The prior quarter-improvement cadence result +must not be presented as the final release result. + +Final reports/raw timings/CPU profiles: /tmp/mobile-motion-final-before/ and +/tmp/mobile-motion-final-after/. Both report no browser errors and all 12 +selections confirmed. The disabled-cost build used the same widget structure +with fixed sizes disabled, progressive occupied chrome restored and the previous +perspective transform path; source was restored byte-for-byte after building. +All private profiling browser/server processes exited. No Android hardware test +was possible. Parent's final browser capture covers the final geometry and +verifies the resting peek reaches its true content bottom. + +Final performance regression checks: 61 workspace/motion tests passed +(/tmp/memwatch/out.Yvac5n), analyzer clean (flutter-analyze.wtLee1). The subsequent +geometry change has its separate parent/animation-lane test evidence.